The week the Farmers/Foremost bifurcation hit week two — and Kemper started looking like an exit.
| Metric | This Week |
|---|---|
| DAILY DIFFS COVERED | 7 |
| P&C APPOINTMENT CHANGES (TX) | 644 |
| AGENCIES WITH P&C MOVEMENT | ~1185 |
| P&C CARRIER BLOCK ACTIONS | 5 |
| CARRIER REDISTRIBUTION PATTERNS | 1 |
SOURCE: TDI SOCRATA API // P&C ONLY
Two consecutive weeks at +39 with no offsetting contraction is no longer a one-off bet. Foremost County Mutual is +43% YoY at $559M; Foremost Insurance Co Grand Rapids is +53% at $142M. The parent's flagship Farmers Property and Casualty book remains down 30%. One holding company is running a deliberate, multi-week, non-coincidental distribution rebuild on its specialty paper while the standard paper continues to shed agencies (Fernando Lopez in Pasadena, this week, is the agency-side mirror image — 13 Farmers-only appointments lost on the same snapshot Foremost added 20 elsewhere). The next Page 14 filing is the test.
| Carrier Family | Added | Removed | Direction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Farmers / Foremost (Zurich) | 39 | 0 | ▲ EXPANDING |
| Homeowners of America (Porch) | 37 | 0 | ▲ EXPANDING |
| Travelers | 18 | 8 | — FLAT |
| Liberty Mutual | 13 | 8 | — FLAT |
| Kemper (Unitrin) | 0 | 14 | — FLAT |
| Redpoint County Mutual | 0 | 6 | — FLAT |
| Progressive | 12 | 0 | — FLAT |
- ›Whether Highpoint Insurance Group reappears with non-Liberty appointments in the next two snapshots — the highest-value follow-up in this brief.
- ›Whether the JNC + four April 17 cluster (JNC, Prairie, Complete Coverage, Endeavor, Axe) keep adding Foremost paper, which would mark them as designated regional outlets rather than new producer relationships.
- ›Kemper exit cadence — if another five-plus agencies lose Unitrin appointments in the next two snapshots, the runoff is mid-execution and the replacement window is tighter than six months.
- ›Whether the Donna Frazier principal of record still holds an active Texas resident license — a license lapse would make this a personal event, not a commercial one.
5 high-interest events identified this week, plus 4 carrier-level narratives with buyer reads — available in the full subscriber brief.
Seven daily diffs (April 13–19, runs 317, 318, 319, 352, 353, 354, 355) from the Texas Department of Insurance Socrata API. 644 P&C appointment events. Distinct-agency count (1,185) is the sum of per-snapshot pair-strip agency counts from the daily pipeline log across the seven diffs (no batch-housekeeping days excluded this week). Carrier entities collapsed into families. Premium context from TDI Page 14 (2024). Phone numbers, filed addresses, named principals, and named buyer reads available in the subscriber edition. [TDI]